Main Content

Tanya Smythe





Tanya resides at Lamb Lake with her husband Mark and is a proud mom of 3 children, 2 daughters-in-law, and 5 grandchildren. Tanya graduated from Indian Creek High School and Indiana University with a Bachelor’s in Psychology. Tanya has over 30 years of experience working with prestigious builders in Florida and Central Indiana. Her passionate and extensive knowledge of real estate has enabled her to develop strong expertise in luxury homes, estate properties, new builds, and lakefront living.

Indianapolis Monthly magazine has named Tanya Smythe a Five Star Real Estate Agent Award Winner for the past 11 years…. 2011-2022. This award is given only to the top 7% of all Real Estate Agents in the 9 County Central Indiana area. The award is based on surveys of recent clients on customer service, knowledge, professionalism, and overall experience with the agent. Tanya has been in the top 10 of all agents based on sales volume for the past 10 years in Johnson County.

Smythe & Co. Real Estate has 15 Agents, 2 Assistants and Offices in Franklin and Columbus.

Smythe & Co. is a boutique real estate company that is proud to be locally owned, providing personal and professional service while obtaining proven results!

Professional Memberships include: MIBOR, National Association of Realtors, Indiana Association of Realtors, IREIBA, and IU Alumni Association, 100 Women Who Care of Johnson County.

Tanya Smythe’s Listings

Sorry we are experiencing system issues. Please try again.

Submit your review

Create your own review

Average rating:  
 3 reviews
by Carey Bottom on Smythe & Co.

I have known Ms. Tanya Smythe since 2009 having purchased a large property (38 acres and 8,000 square foot home with 5 acre lake) she listed at 5306 STATE ROAD 144. During the purchase process she worked very closely with my Buyer’s agent and we effected a purchase efficiently and at a very reasonable price.Subsequent to living on the property, my spouse passed away almost 4 years later and decided immediately to sell the property for many reasons. I decided to list the property very shortly thereafter assuming it would take 1-2 years to sell because of its list price. However, fortunately with Tanya’s excellent abilities I was able to sell and close within 6 months. The sale was complex, but Tanya’s expertise and selling savy was crucial to making it happen as it involved me purchasing multiple properties which were subsequently immediately sold in addition to dividing the land amongst a family situation.Tanya is very professional and can make a sale happen in the most challenging of situations. I actually had interviewed two other realtors when placing my 5306 SR 144 on the market, but was most comfortable with Tanya’s expertise, experience and abilities. Tanya has worked a long time in the profession on the South side and as a consequence has a network of high end sellers and buyers. Many of the properties she handles are high end though she also works in the median price range also. What is most crucial is her unique ability to make sales happen through innovative approaches. She is one of the best in keeping homeowners informed and tracks the market carefully during the listing period. I can only say that she is certainly the best on the south side of Indianapolis. When I first met her she was working for a subsidiary realty company of Duke Homes. I always thought she had the fortitude and capability to go on her own and eventually did so. She has been extremely successful in operating her own company and has expanded accordingly because of the activity she obtains as both a listing and buyer’s agent.

by John And LuAnne Benson on Smythe & Co.

Tanya Smythe was a joy to work with. Very professional and knowledgeable with buying and selling homes. Very responsive with questions and answers to guide us through the process. We recommend her highly!

by Lewie And Jeanette Branscum on Smythe & Co.

Tanya was a big help to us when we purchased our current home. She helped by selling our old home, and went way beyond anything we could ask for in a agent. She was always available for any questions we had, and extremely good to work with. Would recommend her to anyone wanting to purchase a home or sell.

    Skip to content